Psychology From an Empirical Standpoint · Franz Brentano. Routledge () Brentano and Wundt: Empirical and Experimental Bradford. Franz Brentano (). Psychology from an Empirical Standpoint. I. The Concept and Purpose of Psychology. Source: Psychology from an Empirical Standpoint. This standpoint is clearly mirrored in his empirical approach to psychology. It is noteworthy.
|Published (Last):||28 February 2008|
|PDF File Size:||11.3 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||12.89 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Other books in this series. He often refused to discuss criticism, ignored brentaon, and psydhology became more and more isolated, a development that was reinforced by his increasing blindness. It is wholly inconsistent for thinkers of this persuasion to reject, for the reasons mentioned, the question of immortality even in this, its essential sense, though it certainly would be more appropriate to call it immortality of life than immortality of the soul.
And, with his characteristic frankness, even John Stuart Mill has recognised, in his work on Hamilton, that the rejection of substance as the bearer of phenomena is not entirely free from difficulties and uncertainties, especially in the mental realm. Goodreads is the world’s largest site for readers psychilogy over 50 million reviews. The first is a creative phase of renewal and ascending development; the other three are phases of decline, dominated by a turn towards practical interests, by scepticism, and finally by mysticism.
Hence, he does adopt the form of psychologism Husserl seems to have had in mind in the Prolegomena to his Logical Investigationswhere he defines logical psychologism as a position according to which:. In his text Etandpoint Four Phases of Philosophy and Its Current State he defended the metaphilosophical thesis that progress in philosophy can be explained according to principles of cultural psychology.
Furthermore, it offers an additional psydhology The words “phenomenon” or “appearance” are often used in opposition to “things which really and truly exist. According to Brentano, a judgment is true when it is evident, i.
In some cases the intentional object does not exist, but even in these cases there is an object external to the mental act towards which we are directed.
In these two aspects we have a formal analogy between judgments and emotions. The passage clearly suggests, however, that the intentional object towards which we are directed is part of the psychological act. For the individual and even more for the masses, where the imponderable circumstances which impede and promote progress balance each other out, psychological laws will afford a sure basis for action.
Brentano, Psychology There are certain phenomena which once seemed familiar and obvious and appeared to provide an explanation for things which had been obscure.
Just as physical phenomena are under the influence of mathematical laws, and chemical phenomena are under the influence of physical laws, and those of physiology under the influence of all these laws, so psychological phenomena are influenced by the laws governing the forces which shape and renew the bodily organs involved.
Retrieved from ” https: Nor will it be in any way necessary to treat the whole range of so-called psychophysical questions twice, i.
Through Brentano’s illustrious circle of students it exerted a wide influence on philosophy and psychology, especially in Austria, Germany, Poland, and Italy. Experience and AnalysisVienna: He completed the first two books of the work in March Writing and Difference Jacques Derrida. This should not obscure the fact that Brentano did play a crucial role in the process of psychology becoming an independent science. Nevertheless, he candidly acknowledges his belief in immortality. Brentano has often been described as an extraordinarily charismatic teacher.
Internationales Jahrbuch der Franz Brentano Forschung.
Psychology from An Empirical Standpoint : Franz Brentano :
Google Books no proxy archive. In he published Untersuchungen zur Sinnespsychologiea collection of shorter texts on psychology. For example, it will definitely be the task of the psychologist to ascertain the first mental phenomena which are aroused by a physical stimulus, even if he cannot dispense with looking at physiological facts in so staandpoint. After some time his influence was eclipsed by the work of his students, some of who founded philosophical traditions on their own: Brentano became Privatdozent xn, a status that allowed him to go on teaching — but did not entitle him to receive a salary or to supervise theses.
Print Hardcover frrom Paperback. It is a fiction to which no reality of any sort corresponds, or whose existence could not possibly be proved, even if it did exist.
The phenomena of inner perception are a different matter. But it is said to exert a most powerful reciprocal influence upon them. Mental Phenomena in General 1. Description Franz Brentano is one of the founding fathers of twentieth century philosophy, celebrated for introducing the concept of intentionality to philosophy as well as making significant contributions to ethics and logic. Something similar has happened to chemists, and would be happening to psychologists too.
All of the laws of coexistence and succession which these sciences encompass according to others, fall within their domain according to these thinkers, too. The further task of psychology, according to Mill, is to derive from these general and elementary laws of mental phenomena more specific and more complex laws of thought. Nevertheless, their objection to the old definition, too, is related to the fact that on such a definition the limits of knowledge are misunderstood. Hence natural science may not be defined as the science of bodies nor may psychology be defined as the science of the soul.
For all the facts and laws which this branch of inquiry investigates when it is conceived of as the science of bodies will continue to be investigated by it when it is viewed only as the science of physical phenomena.
We, too, use the word “soul” in this sense. Goldman – – Behavioral and Brain Sciences 16 1: He made important contributions to many fields in philosophy, especially to metaphysics and ontology, ethics, logic, the history of philosophy, and philosophical theology.
For the facts which the physiologist investigates and those which the psychologist investigates are most intimately correlated, despite their great differences in character. But this is as far as we can go.
Psychology from An Empirical Standpoint
In general, according to Mill, psychology investigates the laws which govern the succession of our mental states, i. Further Investigations Concerning Psychological Method. Brentano’s distinction between genetic and descriptive psychology strongly influenced Husserl’s development of the phenomenological method, especially in its early phases, a development of which Brentano could not approve for it involved the intuition of abstract essences, the existence of which Brentano denied.
On the other hand, the first task mentioned above undoubtedly belongs to the physiologist.